Pros: Classic good looks; very comfortable; well packed; no major damage; parts fit together well; sturdy when put together.
Cons: Stain doesn't cover undersides of arms between slats or holes where bolts go; two minor chips; finish is uneven; upholstery covered two important holes and had to be cut and fabric edges singed; directions are lousy.
Bottom line: If you're handy and willing to spend time fixing minor flaws (I added stain to areas that had none; glued chips back in place; added stainless steel washers and lock washers to bolts), this is a good investment.