Looks alone? 5 stars, easily. Finish? Questionable. There's a corner on our chair where it wasn't stitched quite right. Also, the cushion has an odd bubble feel in it. It's almost like an air pocket. When you sit down or shift your weight to the left side, it has a pop feel. I've never felt anything like this in a chair before. Worse than these issues is the complete lack of a response from Wayfair when I contacted them. Disappointing.