This product was exactly what I expected from the description and reviews.  I agree with the reviewer that did not like the overlapping on the border, however, I considered this a minimal issue for the price, size, and quality.  I turned that part of the shade to the wall, and it was not noticeable.  I replaced two twenty-year-old off-white shades that were of similar but not exact dimensions, though the difference was not enough to change the overall look.   I like the whiter shades, they look classy on my matching polished nickel desk and floor lamps, and coordinate nicely with the white wood trim around windows, doorways, and floor for an overall polished look.