It looks nice and it's very functional.  I needed a holder that didn't have to be screwed into the wall or cupboard because I live in an apartment, so it fits the bill.  However, I'm not sure about this whole perfect tear thing.  Maybe I am doing it wrong, but I usually have to hold it and pull in order to get it to unroll at all.  Also not sure what the little post that sticks up is for.  Maybe this is designed for right-handed people and since I am left-handed, I'm just not getting how it works.  Either way, it looks nice and is functional.