The quality of the material was very excellent. However the workmanship of the curtain hook openings was not. Some of the openings started below the top of the shower curtain and 1 or 2 of the openings started at the very top of the curtain. The hook openings on the actual shower curtain and the openings on the liner are not aligned correctly so it causes puckers in the shower curtain especially on the end. I really love how it enhances my bathroom as far as color but the visual is off.