The seat: awesome nothing bad about it.
The parts: On the 5 star legs there is a section that has been scratched pretty bad looks like someone took a sander to it. Due to how the stand is set inside the box there is really not any way this could have been damaged from the shippers and it must have been overlooked in the quality control section of vertagear. Does not effect the performance of the chair at all and I can not see it as I would have to lean over to look at it.