I picked this island for the price. It was the cheapest of the 3 I had narrowed down. The item is exactly as pictured and fit perfectly. I've had it for over a month now and I can't remember what I did without it. It's sturdy, holds all my kitchen pots, pans etc. and it's very durable. The top hasn't shown any signs of damage or scuffing in the month. I feel it will really withstand the test of time. I was worried it would be garbage based on the price, but I'm very happy.  Assembly was very quick and easy, single person job, no issues there.  I recommend.