Okay, so here is a real review. Before I purchased this recliner, I was afraid to order it based upon the previous reviews and specific concerns. I am here to give you a 100% honest review.  
1. Yes, it is "real" leather and it feels like it.  It may not be thick Corinthian leather you find in your Rolls Royce (if you drive one), but it's very nice leather. 
2. No, the chair is not lumpy and uncomfortable It was very comfortable for me. I am a 275 pounds tall man, and it felt very comfortable. Yes, my feet did hang over the edge about 4 inches, but ai am 6 foot 2 inches tall. 
3. Yes, the chair oscillating vibrations are not the same as a salon masseuse, but I thought under high vibration, they were great!  Any higher vibration and I think that you would not be able to fall asleep.  
All I can say is, this is a truthful and fair review. I believe that you will be very satisfied with this chair.  I give it 5 stars!