The first order came with a broken diffuser.  The second lamp is OK.  The drum fabric is nice quality and an oatmeal /linen look, not the gray that's in the picture.  It's a nice lamp which supports a dimmer switch, but it's LARGE. The size is right for my room according to the guidelines in sizing on the Birchlane website, but because it's closed (vs an open style light) and it's tall, it looks large for the room.  We may have tried the smaller one but that one doesn't support a dimmer switch.