Beautiful bookcase. The first one was delivered scratched and with a broken door, but Wayfair customer service was amazing and arranged for my replacement to be delivered and the broken one to be removed in the same visit. The new one is exactly what I wanted. Its solid, real wood and well built. The hardware is not an exact match to the Paloma desk I already have, but its not a deal breaker. The two pieces look great in the same room. Im very happy.