I only gave it a 3 because  33 chair backs were damaged, 1 leg of 1 chair was dented and couldnt put extension on, and the holes in the seat were smaller than the  screws so my husband had to re-thread the holes.
I tried to get the back parts replaced along with 1 leg, but they were out of stock and was told to send the chairs back... I thought that would be a pain, so instead, Ill just paint them, and my son straightened out the leg so we could get the extension on.
A 30-minute assembly turned into hours of work because none of the wholes matched the screws.
I do like the looks of the chair, and they are sturdy. I just wish the assembly was easier and there were no damaged parts.