I appreciate these blackout curtains and am using them for 4 windows with both eyelet and rod pocket blackout drapes. When the curtains are pushed back, the ends are very discrete, and it’s easy to get the corner coverage you want with blackout rods when closed. My rating would be more at a 4.5 than 5 due to two minor quibbles 1) Hard to install without small hands 2) Be careful how you measure the space allowances due to the curved edges. I bought them for a 5th window given that the minimum recommended measurements matched a window with cabinets on either side, but they were too wide. Will have to return that one.