These replaced some very dim, old wall sconces and the contrast was so astonishing, I decided to wait 6 months for the honeymoon to be over before reviewing them. I am still delighted with them! They have a clear, bright light that gives lots of light to a dark room and a nice glow when they are dimmed. They have a simple, clean design that does not attract attention, which is precisely what I wanted. The shade is glass and all 4 arrived damage-free. I am extremely pleased with this purchase.