We ended up with two of these sets for a giant deck on a lakeside rental.  We wanted extruded aluminum for it's weight and durability but couldn't afford it.  This is heavier, cast aluminum.  Turns out a blessing in disguise...windstorms do not blow these chairs around!  Very classy, super comfy chairs as they all have armrests.  The dark colors hide dirt.  We don't even use cushions, so no puddling rain.  Many of our repeat guests have thanked us for the upgrade!!  And yes, the top is so flat we can set the table with glassware!