This piece fits perfectly in our mudroom entryway.  This is the first item I ever returned to Wayfair because there were two scratches on the product.  The customer service person I talked to was so kind and she sent me a replacement shelf at no cost.  She suggested I donate the scratched piece to a local charity.  I have always liked Wayfair pieces, but I am so impressed with the company based on this interaction!

The only reason for the 4-star review is that the charcoal color looks black on my computer, but it's really more of a dark grey.  It still works in our space.