What are the reviews said there were no holes cut in the top for the curtain rings, however this is wrong. There are holes that look like buttonholes on the shirt sewn into the top. The two things that I did not like about this product were that it wasnt as long as my other shower curtain and some of the holes were a little too close to the top of the curtain and one tug would probably rip the whole. But for the price of this curtain liner I am extremely happy for the quality of the material and how good it makes my printed  shower curtain pop!