I think I received a return. The hardware package was open and screws and washers were scattered all through the box.  I didn’t get an “open box” deal though. The quality of the wood is pretty disappointing. There are holes and gaps in the pieces of wood that are pressed together.  I had to sand all of the wood edges on the chair pieces because they were completely rough and would’ve given my kids a million slivers.  Neither chair sits flat, they wobble.  Wouldn’t recommend.