The lamp functions well for the space and the overall appearance is OK. The 3 stars are for the wrinkles in the lampshade trim. This shade will be difficult to replace as the harp is a unique style with a flat round connection. I kept the piece because it works for now and completes the quiet sitting area in our guest room. I would not have been pleased if this were to be used in a high trafficmain living space but for the price point, I kept it.