I personally don't love these, but as for reviewing the quality and expectations, they are 5 stars. The wood looks really good, and they are well made. I would prefer four distinct feet rather than the two half-circles, but that's just my taste, and the product doesn't deserve fewer stars for being what it is.

Some reviews mentioned that they were difficult to assemble, and they were a bit tricky, but we eventually got it. That was a relief because I was concerned we were going to end up with loose stools, but they're actually quite solid.