I purchased this as a hope chest for our granddaughter for her 18th birthday.  I ordered the black one.  The box it came in had enough tape on it to cover a small car.  I opened it and the first piece (the top) had a 3" crack across one corner and 2 of the other corners had some damage. I put it back in the box and emailed Wayfair for an exchange.  They replaced it for another and told me to keep the first chest (donate or dispose of it).  The second one came.  The box looked better; we opened it.  We assembled it, even though there was a gouge on front left.  The lid was the last piece to put on it and when we did, the lid has a crown where it doesn't lay flat (the center is raised about a half inch).  I give up!  I love Wayfair but this particular item stinks!