I thought I'd already submitted my review, so I apologize if this is a repeat...  I love this design - and my very picky fiance (you know men!) did, too - so a win-win there!  The holder is entirely metal (except the tp roller thing, which I'm not sure if it's plastic or a lighter metal), and seems very sturdy - I imagine getting many years of use from this.  It also hold the Cottonelle "double rolls" we use, which are 4" wide x 5" diameter - so another win!  Also, as were renting and the very small bathroom is oddly laid out, this will fit very nicely into an unused tiny corner - another win!  The only downside is that I ordered this in black - and, yes, it was black, but under a dark coppery-brownish top coat of paint - I think they were trying to go for a patina look...  So, I've spray-painted it with a semi-gloss black - and it will be awesome!  So, they scored a solid 90-95% on this product - good job!