It only gets an extra star because of the style.  First, like others the harp was messed up at the top where you set  the lampshade.  It was completely crooked and impossible to straighten.  If you screw the finial on all the way it is completely crooked, not just a little.  Second, my shade was bent in three places including the front, so the when the light is on you see creases.  So sadly disappointed, and was so painstakingly wrapped for shipping, I could never get it shipped back properly.  It would end up in a million pieces.  Pass on this lamp, unfortunately everyone is right about how the shade sits due to the finial being crooked.