These were cheap so I got what I paid for but was hoping for better.  For some reason they look so much better on the website. The lamp shade is an unroll and attach to metal frame with velcro.  The vertical seam does not lay flat, looks cheap.  May swap out shades at a later date.   They are short, which I knew before ordering.  One of the wobbles a bit, the bottom is not flat.  I just glue a couple small felt pads.  Love the touch control option.  Plus they dim 3 levels.  The lowest is just a touch above night light brightness.  Enough for me to see since I go to bed much later than spouse but doesn't keep them awake.  took two stars off for horrible shade and wobble.