We’ve have several of these pots in the light tan color.  We are buying to replace older (other brand) pots damaged by fallen trees in last year’s hurricanes. These wayfair pots are fantastic pots and an excellent value for the dollar. The rusty brown color was a gamble and it’s a WIN.  You don’t see plastic: you see a rusty cast iron pot!  Looks fantastic against our flagstone wall and really accents the flowers and greenery which is the point after all.  Very happy with this purchase.