Had to reorder three times - Wayfair really messed up but CS was great.  It is ridiculous it would take three orders to get what I needed. Twice I was sent only one curtain and once one was badly damaged.  I would not say these are good quality.  The velvet is an okay quality for the price.  It has a VERY high sheen and low pile.  They feel very soft and the darken the room nicely - keep in mind they are not black out but darkening and they are great for that purpose.  We ordered the silver and it looks just like the photo.  I do like that they are lined - this certainly puts them in the "better" quality curtain range.  The stitching is mostly straight. If you are looking for a more matte cotton velvet these are not what you want.