we did lots of research and purchased SIX of these bar stools for a new home that will be ready in 5-6 weeks.  we opened one and put it together (very easy, hubby said).  it looks fantastic!  one small wrinkle (pun intended) -- i'm sure it has to do with the curve of the back -- the back upholstery is puckering in the 'bend' a bit.
another possible 'problem' (joke) is that the grand kids think these are carnival rides -- the seat goes up and down pretty easily, almost like a barber chair!
we won't know about wear and tear until move-in, but for right now, we are tickled with our purchase.