If I were rating this solely on the appearance of the fireplace, I'd give it 5 stars, however 2 things made me give it 4. 
1) one of the pre-drilled holes in the back was not in the right position so I was unable to put the screw in and the top piece comes off quite easily even though there are 4 screws tightly securing it, so the screws must not be long enough to go adequately through the two pieces. 
2) shipping time was ridiculous. It took over 3 weeks to receive and tracking is all but impossible. Thankfully, Wayfair's customer service is excellent.