First of all, I thought I was ordering ONE chair.  I did not need two. So great-grandson will make out even better this Christmas.  The color is much "redder" than it appeared online and I wish there'd been an option as it does not match the antique desk my husband refinished for our little guy.  BUT - as the size is right, he is going to get the desk, and two chairs.  Good news?  He is going to have a new baby brother or sister to share it with in the future.  The chairs are well-made - and appear very nice. Just wish there were color options AND you could purchase just ONE chair.  As for a rating?  I'd give it a 5 if the color wasn't so different.  For quality they get a 6 -- the other reasins, a 6!  Thanks Birch Lane.