This is a great island for the kitchen space. I may have taken off a half star due to the difficulty in tightening up the screws on the side that hold the paper towel holder. Seems to be a bit of a flaw. But it has held up fine. I think that is because we are empty nesters and we do not have children using/abusing this piece of furniture. It looks like a solid and fine piece of furniture and we have received many compliments. Had it for nine months or so and it's held up well. Took my husband a while to assemble but wasn't a problem.....just takes patience. Overall, quite happy with this purchase. Btw.....The reviews on this sight are very helpful and make a huge difference in helping me choose just what I'm looking for.