The mirror arrived on time but when we opened the box, not only was it the wrong mirror, but it was also shattered.  The part number on the box and the packing slip both had the correct number so we think it left the factory that way (and probably left shattered as well), so this is no way Wayfair's fault.  

A phone call to Wayfair was all it took and they just asked that we email a picture of the broken mirror.  The correct one showed up a few days later, unbroken, and we installed it.

Pros: Looks nice.  Very simple lines, no wacky scrollings or engravings.
Cons: None