This shelf does look good. It goes together solid too. I like the overall size and the variable sizes of the shelves are nice and versatile. It holds much more than you would think. I took off a star because some of the pieces were scratched and chipped. We were able to put those sides to the back. I also didn't like their solution for the screw holes. It's just vinyl stickers that go over the 1/2 inch holes. I wish they were plugs instead, but minor issue.