I love these stools! I purchased the counter-height as the framework of my island sits pretty low under the actual counter. Though I wish they were a couple of inches taller, its nothing that a pillow can't fix. That being said, I find these stools quite comfortable such that they do not need any pillows or cushioning even for extended periods of sitting. They are super cute (I selected the bright blue) and pair well both with my more modern colorful decor and the more muted speckled granite of my kitchen. Other reviewers have noted that the paint does mark up/scratch easily, which is true. In my case, they were certainly packaged well with appropriate protection, and as long as you don't plan on kicking these chairs around it seems they will hold up and look nice for a long time. Overall I am quite satisfied and am considering purchasing an additional set.