Third time was a charm.  I ordered a couple other rugs for my living room, but they weren't quite right.  I'm so glad I found the Adderley Shag Charcoal Gray rug from Wayfair.  I ordered the 7 x 10, but I wish it came in a 9 x 12.  It still looks nice in our living room and shouldn't show the dirt that our dog tracks in!