If I were rating only on looks, I would give a 4/5. They are really cute. However, they are not comfortable enough for daily use or for lounging in, watching TV.  I am using them in a room where they won't get much use and they look really nice there. Another concern is quality. They are very lightweight, not at all sturdy.  The fabric does loose it's form after sitting in and I am always straightening it out. Very little cushioning. Good news, the plaids match up. I don't mean to be negative, it all depends on what you are using the chair for.