I'd like to give this rug 3.5 starts... As other reviewers said, the texture is rough so that it's a little harsh on barefoot. (Personally, I like it since it feels like foot-massage.) And the fibers are coming off now - but the shedding(?) may decrease over time, I hope. I really like the color and its look, and the smell of hay. :-) Also, the non-skidding backing is a definite plus.Pros: color, backingCons: a bit of shedding, texture