I ordered both the Successi pulls (left/bottom) and Skylight by Hickory Hardware (right/top), and although the Successi were the ones I opted to return, they were still nice. Heavy brass with a sort of hammered-look texture. My picture shows the color/finish difference between the two brands; the Skylight (color: "Elusive Gold Nickel") has a higher-shine brushed look. They are otherwise basically identical in size, shape and weight. 

My one recommendation on these pulls is to modify how they're listed in the Wayfair store and put the size measurement in the title so I can see at a single glance which sizes and quantities of each I'm purchasing. Takes too much time clicking in and out and I got confused, so that was a negative on the shopping experience.