Look wise and comfort wise, we are very happy.  
Packaging wise though, it was a gong show.  The hardware packages were open and the pieces spilled into the package.  My husband had to bang washers out of the seats.  The bigger problem, aside from the inconvenience and potential for losing hardware, is the grease on the machined parts which could have transferred to the brand new beige chair.  Not the smartest set up I've ever seen.