So far I really like these chairs.  I'll be honest I settled on the leather because I have 4 boys and knew they would be easier to keep clean.  The nail head finish is a nice accent - it dresses the leather up.  The chairs were extremely easy to put together. They seems to be very sturdy!  One of the chairs had a pilot hole drilled incorrectly.  I contacted Birch Lane ASAP and within (3) days I had a new chair.  The service has been impeccable!!