4 stars so far, maybe more to come, easy set up, helps if you have a specialty bit for your drill, you can start it and then finish with hand tightening. Took me an hour but I wasn’t rushing. Can be put together with one person. Placed our new box springless mattress on top, (they told us to walk on it to help it expand) so it held us walking on top of it, seems solid so far. No creaking so far, the “velvet” isn’t really velvet, it’s just a micro suede, not bad, but not as lush as one would want.