4 out of 5 because the chair is what they say it is.  We bought 5 of them and they came with all the pieces! We are happy with the looks.  It is hard to find white chairs, and this is the best I found in this price range.  If they do not last, at least I didn't spend 400 to 500 per chair.

Pros: good size seat, simple design, but not cheap looking
Cons: assembly took a little time, expected though