I ordered the black counter stools for a busy restaurant
The Good:
They look expensive, nicely detailed, the backs taper to a pretty narrow point
The physical texture of wood grain is visible through the black paint- these don't look like they are plastic
The thick, clear rubber casters nice and are attached with a recessed set screw
They are extremely light weight
No assembly required
The Bad: 
The black paint will probably chip 
The backs are too low to use as back support
The Ugly:
I have seen the "red" version of these and they are definitely more dark orange than red

Pros: Great value, lightweight, commercial warranty
Cons: The red is not really red, there is no touch-up paint available for purchase