These stools are exactly what I was looking for.  I have had them now for nine months and am still happy with them.  I was nervous about the wood top - how it would look and the color.  The wood is real and is a nice brown (not orange) color.  It is a medium tone with a nice grain.  The metal is shiny and not matte.  There were only a few minor scraps where the black coating had rubbed off, but not noticeable at all.  Assembly was easy. The stools are very sturdy and are quite comfortable!  We got the stools for our new home, and so the pictures included are from before we finished the kitchen - but it goes perfect with my rustic industrial theme!  Very happy with this purchase and would definitely recommend!