The look & quality of the rug material seems to be the best but could only give it a 2 rating. One corner has an unforgiving ripple & won't lay flat even after 4 weeks of having flattening weight on it. After measuring, I'm guessing the carpet was slightly miss-cut & when the binding was applied caused a permanent ripple. Wayfair has sent me a replacement & I can only hope that it will be ok. I've got to get some help to get my heavy dining table moved out of the room again to put down the replacement.