I am very disappointed in these trays. Others have called them rustic. I say they look cheap. The seams on the tray, along the bottom and sides, are filled with white wood putty, not stained over. They look unfinished. The finish is a dull matte brown. Plus I did not realize that the two trays would be different sizes. My bad. Too much trouble to pack them up and return, so I will keep them for day to day use. I wouldn't put them out if I had guests.