I ordered two stools. The one was perfect, but the other one had a very small crack down the one leg and a small smudge on the seat like the paint got bumped before it dried. Not worth the hassle of returning as both things were minor. 
I give an "excellent" to the manufacturing of these stools. There are very sturdy and the hardware is great.  There were very easy to assemble and have no wobble. Nice and heavy. I'm considering buying a third one.