I love the half moon and square shaped rug. They are vibrant in color and nice and thick! They are 5 stars! Although, the larger rug is not as vibrant in color, almost like it is faded. And not as thick material as the smaller ones. That rating would be 3 stars. If they were all in the same room, you would definitely notice the difference. But since they are not, it still looks ok. I like it.