Hanging up as the finished product I think they look nice. Drilling the screws into the shelf caused both shelves to crack but you cant tell when they are hanging because it faces the wall (see pictures). There is definitely a top and a bottom of the shelf because one side is not well painted versus the other (see picture). Also it seems they stained/painted the shelves and immediately slapped the sticker on because when I carefully peeled the sticker off the shelf the paint underneath the sticker was splotchy so I hung that shelf up higher so you couldnt see the imperfection (see picture) We were also missing four long screws and four wall anchors. Had to use ones we had at home. Overall I am not going to return them because I got them half off for $33 and they look fine hanging up but had I paid full price they would probably have gone back.