I should probably give this a 4.5.  The chairs are great quality.  They were easy to assemble.  The color was perfect.  They are solid and comfortable.  The ONE complaint that I have is that they do not include any type of sticker or plugs that approximate the color of the chairs to cover the screws needed to put them together.  It seems like this would be a relatively inexpensive thing to include to make the finished chairs look truly finished rather than leaving the brass screw heads that are the size of a nickle exposed.