I just assembled this chair yesterday, but so far it is perfect... and I am very picky. I agonized for weeks over which chair to get for my nursery, and I'm so glad I went with this one. It's very comfortable (not too firm or too soft, good arm rest width, and the fabric is very soft). It doesn't make any noise when swiveling or rocking. The recline function is easy to use and the footrest is easy to lock back into place. The assembly is about the easiest thing in the world... no hardware; the back just slides into brackets in the base. The chair is just as pictured on the website and looks great. And it's greenguard gold. I couldn't be happier with this purchase, especially since there are plenty of chairs selling for twice as much.