We purchased two of these lamps, and really like them.  I rated this a 4-star since one of the finials was drilled  just a little off-center of straight, but my hubs fixed it in a jiffy, just by bending things a bit.  Really, not a problem,  but not perfect..

Pros: They look great!
Cons: The finial was drilled incorrectly, but not really a proble,m at all!