I received this later in the day when I was preparing my casserole for the oven. In my haste to assemble it I did not examine all the pieces. I have assembled 6 of these in the past so I knew what I was doing. The bottom shelf was perfect, the middle shelf perfect as well but of course, with my luck, the top shelf has a long very noticeable divot running across the middle of it! I am a 66 year old disabled woman with no patience so I am not about to disassemble and reassemble it. Other than that. the white and black end table is a nice addition to my black and white check themed bedroom. I wish I could have given it 5 stars but....