Great chairs! I'm hesitant to give these chairs 5 stars since we JUST got them, but so far they are great! Very comfy and seem solid/sturdy. Quality seems good but we will see how they holds up. The chairs came as a seat separate, with the metal legs alone as a unit (see pic). You don't have to screw each leg in separately, which is nice and seems sturdier. AND the screw holes all actually lined up! The only thing I will say - which is important - is that the seat height dimensions on here are WRONG (which was a good thing for us!). This site says they are 23" but they're actually 19/20" like normal dining chairs. I have no idea how they measured 23"...? We looked at the picture and said "that can't be right" and ordered them anyways..and were happy to find they are as tall as normal dining chairs. Perfect. :)