Positive: I like the color and the fabric and they do a good job of blocking out the east sun in the morning.
Negative: There was a large gap in the seam at the top (I chose to mend it myself rather than attempting to return them.)  There are deep creases in the fabric from being packed so tightly that I fear no amount of washing and cool ironing will ever flatten out.
All in all, they are decent curtains that do what I bought them to do.  If you are particular about how things look and don't want creases in your curtains, these might not be for you.