These vases are exactly what I was hoping for.  A lot of reviewers complained that they are too small but they were the perfect size for me.  They were a great price on sale and were packaged well.  They have a good weight to them and seem to be made very well.  They also came with 3 little pads on the underneath side so they don't scratch what they're sitting on.  They have a smooth glaze on the top half and a rougher finish on the bottom half.  I have included a picture with a soda can for scale.  I can't wait to incorporate these into my living room decor.  Very happy with my purchase.