Overall  4 stars, RECOMMEND!
Shipping  5 stars, as usual, Wayfair’s delivery is top notch.  Received quickly and accurately
Quality of fabric  5 stars, I love the feel and softness of the fabric. 
Ease of application  4 stars, this was definitely easy to put on the sofa, but I’m a perfectionist, so making it appear perfect without bunching took a bit of time
Fit  3 stars, I think this is mostly user error and it still looks good but it is a little bit big for my specific sofacouch

Other observations  
1.  my cats LOVE this slip cover.  One has not left the couch since I put it on!!!   I can see some of the paw prints in the fabric too, which doesn’t bother me but I did want to share for fellow pet owners. 
2. Just coming out of the box, there are wrinklesstreaks in the fabric.  I do think they will lessen over time though.