I purchased two of these chairs just about a year ago.  Out of the box they were “not bad”, although the grey stain on them was sloppy, uneven, and just not what was expected.  We live in a very mild climate and are shocked to see how poorly these have held up.  Although the bolts have been tightened several times, the chairs are “rickety” and feel like they could collapse under my 120 pounds.  When new, you could see the wood seems, but now those have split and pieces look like they may come apart eventually.  Very sad, but we’re going to need to replace these, soon!