Hi, unfortunately I cannot give a review on the replacement canopies.......Yet. You see, it's only the month of April here in Manitoba, Canada and winter is still under way here. Just had a snowstorm on the 6th. So, I will not be able to put up the canopies for at least another 2 months. But from what I see of them now is that they seem to be made of good quality fabric and have full confidence that they will be just fine.