It does the work. However, one needs to secure the bars, so they wouldn't move. I had to use "Self-Adhesive Rubber Feet" (Thin Clear Cylindrical Bumpers sold in Amazon-cheap). Now the bars don't move from their places. Also, the upper clips are for thicker bars to hold. If you don't have it, it is hard for it to hold on to the shelf. In this case, I used bubble packing plastic (simple and cheap-you can get it from Amazon, Walmart, Lowes or HomeDepot, etc.). I cut them in a certain length and width (like ribbons); I rapped them over the thin bar (you know what I mean). They don't move once you roll over those thin bars for multiple times. When you obtain the certain thickness, there you will have your own bar for clips to hold on tight. They wouldn't move any more. I wish I didn't have to come up with all of these tactics, that's why I gave 4 star. Hope that helps you when you have hard time to set up the closet kit. Thank you.