I ordered two of these and both of them had pretty noticeable scratches.  Thought I could live with it but when held up to the light they are too noticeable.  All scratches were at the same height on the glass all the way around so perhaps a manufacturing issue.  Pictures only show the worst scratches, but there were others.  
Update:  Wayfair replaced these for us and we are happy with them. Replacement process was super-easy!