I purchased the desk, return, and smaller filing cabinet and bought this piece to complete my home office.  I was expecting the rounded desk, but received the rectangular desk, so that was a bit disappointing.  This piece was a bit more difficult to put together than any of the others but it looks good with the other pieces.  I will say that if you put legal files in a portion of the drawer, the remaining portion can only be used for letter size files.  I was hoping for more room for my larger files.   There was one ding in the back of the top piece, but fortunately once it was together, it cannot be seen.