These are great stools. I ordered 4, and I get compliments all the time! There were a few scratches and dings when I unboxed, but nothing major and nothing that doesn't happen within the first few months of use anyway. There are similar looking stools on this site, but these are stronger (check weight capacity!) and worth the extra money. The back does hit my island when it swivels, and the finish has worn/chipped away in that spot on all four, and cat hair is attracted to that black metal base! But, I am still quite happy with them. They are comfortable and sturdy and beautiful. I do recommend.