I purchased these chairs to fill in while two vintage barrel chairs are being reupholstered.  Maybe it is because I am used to the quality of my vintage chairs, but these look a little cheap to me. They are sturdy...cushions are hard but seem to be softening up a bit. They are totally as described, so I don't want to give them too low a rating. Modern. They will fill our space fine until my others are ready...then I will repurpose at our office or sell online.