Nice colors, just the right size for my desk chair to protect my floor while still looking attractive. (I hate the look of the plastic floor protectors.) It did come wrinkled and smelly, but after a day on my balcony it flattened out and no more smell. The one star off is because it is not evenly circular. It is a bit crooked on one side. Since it is semi under my desk, I was able to turn it to hide that aspect.