Probably a 4.5 out of 5. The pillows look great and feel SO soft -- almost like a sueded material. (As soon as I put them on the sofa our two cats both claimed one as their new throne.) The color is accurate to that shown on the site. 

I didn't realize the pattern design is only on one side -- that's on me -- so they aren't reversible. But that's a minor issue. 

My other quibble is that they are pretty thin compared to other pillows. I realize they are squeezed flat for shipping and they did fluff up some after having a few days to air out, but they still aren't as thick as I'd thought they'd be. 

Overall though, they're a win. I'm pleased with them and they look great in person.