Had I bought these of the current sale price they are at, I'd feel they were perfectly fine for their price. As it is, I paid nearly double for them and was not pleased. They were also advertised as black but have a definite bronze edge all around the rim, so I had to spray paint them to get them to match my master bath. They are doing the job well, and they look great, I'm just not happy I paid nearly double for what feels a bit like a flimsy product that was misrepresented and I had to alter upon receipt to make it match the description.