We like this chair, and it's a decent price. It got here within a week, and though the outer packaging was alarmingly damaged, the pieces inside were just fine. It's fairly easy to put together, and no tools necessary (oh, correction: my husband said just his "pythons" [muscles] were needed). Even knowing the dimensions of the chair, it feels narrower than you might expect. 
As far as aesthetics, I chose the lighter brown, which was more expensive, specifically because that one looked more "weathered," and I wasn't looking for something shiny. However, this lighter brown looks like the dark brown, but shinier, and not quite as expensive-looking as the photos. Still, it's as described, though not exactly what we expected. But we gave it four stars because it was a good price, easy assembly, and quick shipping.