The lamp bases are pretty nice. There is some pitting where the ceramic glaze must have bubbled up.  It is not very noticeable. However, the lampshades are pretty awful.  At least the ones I got in my package.  You have to position the shades around metal hoops to velcro together the  edges.  The shade part on both  of mine is slightly longer on one end than the other one it is supposed to meet with  So automatically the shade is mis matched at the seam.  Also, the way one was packed left it with a malformation at the seam - it bows inward.  I give the lamps a 4 and the shades a 2