Great looking bookcase, the materials seem solid and it is sturdy when assembled. It is exactly what we wanted, so give the final product a 5. Instructions aren’t great but are sufficient. My main complaint, and it’s minor, was with the packaging of the bolts and washers. There are two size bolts. All the small bolts require washers, some of the larger bolts require washers, but all the washers come already on the larger bolts. There was a moment of confusion since this isn’t clarified by the instructions and the bolts and washers aren’t labeled. Even with this it only took 26 minutes to assemble. Very happy with the final product.