When this shelf arrived, the bottom shelf was split along one edge. Wayfair sent a new shelf and gave me a credit on a future order, which was appreciated. But the replacement shelf arrived with the finish chipped on one corner. Also, there are pegs holding the top and bottom halves of the shelf in place before you insert screws, and those pegs were positioned in such a way that the top and bottom  of the shelf are slightly out of alignment on mine.