The comforter set itself is very nice, we ordered it in purple. It has a nice sheen to it, is warm and soft. I rated it a 4 because of the size, we ordered a queen but due to the thickness of our mattress, the comforter is short on the sides, and probably length too, but since we have a sleigh bed, you cannot notice that.  Had we ordered a king, the bed skirt and shams would not have fit properly, so there really was no good way to order the set. The only other issue we've had, the dog claws do snag where the diamond patterns are. :(