This came scratched on both chairs. Given it’s black metal, the scratches are fairly obvious. Otherwise the stools look nice, the fabric material is good quality and the mustard yellow chairs match photos. The adjustable mechanism is clunky though, not as smooth as say an office chair. The bases are not heavy enough for the stool - it feels top heavy and wobbly when extended to a higher height. If they arrived unscratched and had heavier bases these would be a 4-4.5 star.