This umbrella gets 5 stars for looks.  It has a quaint shape, the color is vivid, and it looks great on the patio.  I would give it 3 stars for quality.  It does not have a quality feel to it, the edge of the fabric has come detached from the frame several times, and the crank feels as though it could break at any moment.  It's a shame it isn't better made - because it looks cute and serves the purpose.