I ordered two of these and I'm happy enough with them.  They look fake, but I have them up high flanking my fireplace mantel so you can't really tell.  If I had them in a different spot where I could see the detail more, I would be less happy.  The reason I'm only giving them three stars is that both came with very different colored pots.  One is more of a gold color, the other is gray.  I didn't figure it was worth sending for a replacement since both colors go in my room, but it's a noticeable difference and it is irritating.  Overall though, they look decent, and the price is good.