Have only had this a few weeks, but boy, has this made recycling easier along with trash. Both compartments hold a good amount. We are diligent about recycling and do empty this often to our outside can, but the pail makes it an easy task. I, like other reviews, find occasionally it listens in on conversations and will open, definitely NOT a deal breaker. I even hear my Granddaughter, "open can" then, "thank you!" If you have the right space, this is great! simplehuman continues to come up with awesome products, so, Thank You!! Max