I like this caddy and the way it's laid out. The book rest is really nice. I also love how compact it is - I just rest it against the wall outside the tub when not in use and it takes practically no space. The problem I have with it is that my old-style tub is built into the wall, so on the left hand side there is no ledge or anything to rest the edge of the caddy on. I had to rig it with a plastic hook and super glue, which works fine. Just an fyi when purchasing - make sure you have 2 solid edges of a tub to use.