I wish I could give this 4.5 instead of just 4. It really does look more expensive than it was. We opted for the black because I have been stung by Wayfair once before with a wood coloring not being what I thought it would. The paint or veneer or whatever it is on this looks great, and it came packaged very well (so much styrofoam!), so it arrived in perfect condition. The .5 star I took off was because: this thing comes in like 100 pieces and it took myself and my husband 2.5 hours to put together. It was a bear. Secondly, the top drawer is for some reason, not the same distance apart than the bottom 2 drawers, leaving a gap that only I would notice. This is not a user error, this is how it seems to be designed. Overall, very happy with my West Elm knockoff at 1/3 of the price!